darchildre: a crow being held in one hand.  text:  "bird in hand" (bird in the hand)
[personal profile] darchildre
So, tonight I went to see Thor.


I went in telling myself not to rant about things that are wrong as compared with the mythology, so I am notably not talking about that. Except in one instance, because I'm sorry, I could not get past this, Laufey is Loki's mother. I realize that's confusing because he gets called Loki Laufeyjarson and usually that's a patronymic but, y'know, Laufey. Not a dude.

I'm done now.

Other than that, I thoroughly enjoyed it. I really like Chris Hemsworth's Thor. He is...well, that's pretty much exactly how I picture Thor*. Big and brash and kind and really enthusiastic about smashing stuff. He was perfect. Tom Hiddleston is not at all how I picture Loki but he's very pretty (that scene where he was in human clothes was especially nice) and I enjoyed him and his ridiculous daddy issues and identity crisis. I look forward to seeing him again. Anthony Hopkins is likewise not Odin but he's Anthony Hopkins and that's always fun. And all the humans were nifty.

The movie does feel a lot like set up, but that is the curse of the superhero movie. Now we have the origin story out of the way, so we can do more interesting things next time. I would definitely watch more Thor movies and I'm totally looking forward to The Avengers.

Maybe I should read Thor comics.





*Let's talk about how it's deeply weird to watch superhero movies about one's gods. On one level, I'm watching a silly but entertaining superhero movie and on another level, I'm watching a story that sort of nominally is about stuff that is, y'know, religiously important to me and occasionally having weird moments where things click and resonate. Mr Hemsworth's Thor smiles all the time, for example, and I'd never really thought about it but of course Thor does. Thor is that kind of god. There was a scene where Loki and Frigga were talking (Loki and Frigga are the gods I probably talk to most, though not generally at the same time) and she's kinda sorta his mom in this film and she obviously had so much love for him. And, just, of course, because Frigga is the All-Mother and she has that boundless love for everyone. Of course Heimdall can see Jane Foster from Asgard - Heimdall watches over all of us.

(Alas, I did not have such moments concerning Odin or Loki because the film's Odin and Loki are incredibly far from being the Odin and Loki I know. Ah, well.)

And it's bizarre because how the hell do you talk to people about that? "So I had this religious insight during this cheesy comic book movie..." Deeply weird.

Date: 2011-05-08 07:43 am (UTC)
polarisnorth: a silhouetted figure sitting on the moon, watching the earthrise (Default)
From: [personal profile] polarisnorth
If you read Thor comics, read the Walt Simonson run from the 80s. It's the best thing that ever happened to the series. JMS's run from a couple years back is also pretty good.

Date: 2011-05-08 04:24 pm (UTC)
finch: (Default)
From: [personal profile] finch
I agree with you about Thor 100% percent - I haven't dealt with him alot but Chris Hemsworth was dead freaking on with my experience of him. Comic!Loki is far enough off the canon that I don't really associate him with actual!Loki at all (though, agreed, I want more of him in suits and stuff in Avengers, pls). Anthony Hopkins didn't look like I see Odin at all, but something in his voice and the way he played it felt right regardless. Same for Heimdall - the look was off-model, but the way he carried himself made up for it.

Weirdly, the only casting thing that I couldn't quite get past was the fact that Sif was a brunette. XD

The Simonson run on Thor is some of the best comics period, IMO, but the current stuff that Matt Fraction is doing is also excellent, and the Thor: The Mighty Avenger series was great if tragically cut short eight issues in.

(Also, having seen Jesus Christ: Vampire Hunter and Dogma while I was still nominally Christian, I didn't think a movie about my gods was that weird. But I'm odd.)

Date: 2011-05-09 03:58 am (UTC)
silveradept: A kodama with a trombone. The trombone is playing music, even though it is held in a rest position (Default)
From: [personal profile] silveradept
Lots of people have good religious experiences from silly movies and comic books. The graphic format, combined with good scripting, makes for epics that sing just as well as any saga.

Profile

darchildre: a candle in the dark.  text:  "a light in dark places". (Default)
Renfield

September 2024

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Feb. 1st, 2026 12:32 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios